PLA Navy Obtains New-Generation Submarines
http://www.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2.../21/13404.shtmlPLA Navy Obtains New-Generation Submarines
Dr. Alexandr Nemets
Thursday, Nov. 21, 2002
In July 2001, in an article about PLA Navy modernization written jointly with Dr. Thomas Torda (PLA Navy: From 'Green Water' to 'Blue Water'), the author gave the most recent information available (from June-August 2001) regarding the "093 project" nuclear attack submarine:
By mid-2001, Huludao Military Shipbuilding Plant, in northeastern Liaoning province, finished construction of one submarine or, more probably, two submarines of this kind; this submarine (or these submarines) participated, in August 2001, in PLA's large-scale Dongshan maneuvers in the Taiwan Strait.
For about a year, no new information about the "093" project was available. Finally, several weeks ago the author got an opportunity to read the article "PLA missile forces" in the June 2002 issue of the Taipei-based journal Zhonggong Yanjiu (China Communism Research). The most interesting theses of the article are as follow:
* By 2000-2001, China, with heavy Russian assistance, finished developing and mastered production of HN(Hong Niao)-2 and HN-3 Land Attack Cruise Missiles (LACMS). All of them are capable of carrying nuclear warheads.
* The HN-2 series includes three varieties namely, HN-2A and HN-2B for ground launching, with a range of 1,800 km, and HN-2C for submerged launching from submarines, with a 1,400-km range. According to reliable sources, HN-2Cs are installed on PLA Navy Song-class diesel-electric submarines; they could be vertically launched from standard 533-mm torpedo tubes.
* The HN-3 series, with a range of 2,500-3,000 km and maximal rate of 0.9 Mach (speed of sound), includes the HN-3A variety for ground launching and the HN-3B variety for submerged launching from the "093 project" nuclear attack submarine.
* China (no doubt with heavy assistance from Russia) is presently engaged in developing "super-advanced" LACM with a range of 4,000 km.
(end of Zhonggong Yanjiu theses)
According to data available, by the end of 2002 the PLA Navy commissioned five Song-class diesel-electric submarines (constructed at Wuhan Shipyard in Hubei province of Central China) and two "093 project" nuclear attack submarines. It looks as if all of them are equipped with long-range LACMs, mostly with nuclear warheads.
Let's be grateful to Russian cruise missile designers in Reutovo (an eastern suburb of Moscow), Dubna (a town about 150 km north of Moscow) and Yekaterinburg (a major city in the Ural zone), as well as to St. Petersburg-based Rubin Bureau, the major designer of Russian and Chinese nuclear and diesel-electric submarines.
They were initially supposed to construct the "093 project" submarine as an improved variety of the Soviet Victor III nuclear attack submarine equipped with the following major weapons:
* submerge-launched anti-ship cruise missile with a range of less than 100 km;
* anti-submarine missile with 40-km range.
It seems that the "093 project" equipped with HN-3B long-range LACMs is a greatly improved variety of Victor III.
Probably the PLA has no intention of constructing additional "093 project" submarines, which belong, in general, to the world level of the 1980s. However, in 2003-2005, the PLA would get several more Song-class submarines equipped if the data of U.S., U.K. and Taiwanese military intelligence are reliable with mid-range HN-2C LACMs.
By mid-2002, three major Russian shipyards Severnaya Verf in St. Petersburg, SevMash plant in Severodvinsk (near Arkhangelsk city on the White Sea) and Komsomolsk-na-Amure Shipyard started construction of eight units of the "super-Kilo 636" diesel-electricl submarine for PLAN needs. These submarines will be at least as noiseless as Victor III/"093 project." The major weapons of this upgraded submarine include:
* six tubes for 533-mm "standard" torpedoes;
* Club submerge-launched anti-ship cruise missile system with 200-km range;
* Shkval sophisticated torpedo system.
According to estimates of Russian experts, both Club and Shkval have no analogs among the world weapon systems of these classes. Probably the "super-Kilo 636" belongs to the world level of the second half of the 1990s and, by overall combat potential, surpasses Song-class submarine and doesn't yield greatly to the "093 project" submarine.
According to the initial contract, construction of the "super-Kilo 636" should be finished in 2006. However, some Hong Kong sources claim that (a) PLAN will get these eight submarines by 2005 and (B) Wuhan Shipyard, the major Chinese constructor of diesel-electric submarines, will obtain at the same time the "super-Kilo 636" manufacturing technology.
That's not all.
In the second half of 1999 to the first half 2000, there were a lot of messages regarding PLA Navy interest in purchasing Russian Akula-class "noiseless" submarines. However, PLAN interests in this area had shifted somewhat by 2002.
In December 2001, the Russian Navy commissioned its second (by other sources, first) "upgraded Akula" or Akula II-class nuclear attack Gepard. It is considered the most advanced in the Russian Navy inventory of nuclear attack submarines. Gepard weaponry includes:
* Granit (SS-N-21 Sampson) submarine-launched LACMs with a range of approximately 3,000 km; they are usually equipped with nuclear warheads.
* Yakhont supersonic ship-to-ship missiles, with a maximal rate of 3 Mach (1,000 m/s) and a range of about 300 km.
* Advanced torpedoes and missile-torpedoes.
The submarine could dive to depths of 520-600 m and sail autonomously for 100 days. Gepard was built at Severodvinsk Shipyard. Two more Akula II-class submarines remained half-built in Severodvinsk at the beginning of 2002. The Russian Defense Ministry has no money to finish them.
At the same time, one or two Akula I submarines remained unfinished for the same reason at Komsomolsk-na-Amure Shipyard. However, Akula I, as a "slightly obsolete" model, is presently of no particular interest to the PLA Navy.
Very probably, in 2003-2005, the PLA Navy will concentrate efforts on purchasing Akula-II submarines from Russia. Some sources give $2 billion as the possible bargaining figure. At the same time, Huludao Shipyard could get the technology to manufacture Akula II.
Some reports in early November in the Hong Kong media confirm this conclusion.
Dr. Alexandr V. Nemets is co-author of "Chinese-Russian Military Relations, Fate of Taiwan and New Geopolitics."
